There's a particular kind of agency problem that doesn't look like a problem at all.

Clients are happy.
Teams are busy.
Revenue keeps coming in.

On the surface, everything's working.

But underneath, delivery is becoming more expensive than it needs to be. Not because anyone is doing a bad job, but because everyone is trying to be helpful.

I see this most often in agencies of around 15–35 people. Big enough that informal ways of working no longer hold. Small enough that goodwill and experience are still doing a lot of heavy lifting.

Nothing is 'broken' in an obvious way. But margin keeps disappointing. Teams feel stretched. And leaders can't quite explain where the profit went.

How helpfulness turns into a cost

It usually shows up in small, reasonable decisions:

• A project runs a week longer than planned, but the budget stays the same
• A retainer quietly absorbs an extra 10–15 hours a month
• A client asks for "one more tweak" and no one wants to push back
• A freelancer gets booked last minute because internal capacity isn't clear

Each decision makes sense in isolation. Everyone's being flexible. Keeping momentum. Keeping clients happy.

But stack those decisions together, month after month, and they quietly erode margin.

Often by 4–6% of revenue. Sometimes more.

And because the work still gets delivered, this doesn't feel like failure. It feels like service.

The real issue isn't margin — it's control during delivery

Most agencies only look at profitability after the work is finished. By then, all the decisions that mattered have already been made.

Margin erosion doesn't happen in finance reports. It happens in delivery:

• When overruns aren't visible early
• When extra work isn't formally acknowledged or agreed
• When resourcing is reactive rather than planned
• When no one is accountable for the commercial health of live work

In the absence of clear operational guardrails, teams default to being helpful. And helpful is expensive.

Not just financially, but emotionally. Because the cost is absorbed by people; through longer days, blurred boundaries, and constant reactivity.

Why this often feels cultural (but isn't really)

Many agencies tell me, 'That's just how we work'.

Fast. Flexible. Client-first.

But what looks like culture is usually design.

• When there's no shared view of capacity, people say yes
• When scope isn't clearly defined, work expands
• When delivery decisions aren't linked to profit, margin becomes accidental

This isn't about people caring too much. It's about the system not making trade-offs visible.

What changes when helpfulness is constrained (not removed)

The agencies that improve this don't become rigid or slow. They become clearer.

They introduce simple, deliberate constraints:

• Clearer scoping and pricing assumptions
• Basic capacity visibility a few weeks ahead
• Live tracking of projects, not just end-of-month reviews
• Explicit handling of scope changes
• Clear ownership for noticing drift early

Same clients.
Same team.
Same revenue.

Just fewer leaks.

And the impact shows up quickly (often within a couple of months) because variable delivery costs drop and work stops drifting past its profitable window.

A simple place to start

If you want to sense-check whether helpfulness is costing you, look at your active work and ask:

• Where are we regularly doing more than we agreed?

• Which projects or retainers rely on goodwill to stay on track?

• Where are teams compensating for lack of clarity with extra effort?

You don't need to fix everything at once. You just need those answers to be visible.

Because once they are, being 'helpful' becomes a conscious choice, not an automatic one.

Being client-focused doesn't mean absorbing unlimited cost.
Being flexible doesn't mean being vague.
And good service shouldn't come at the expense of a calm, profitable operation.

Helpful isn't the enemy.

Uncontrolled helpfulness is.

And most agencies are already paying for it, just not in a way that's easy to see.

💜 If you'd like to explore how to make your operations AI-ready and get other top operational tips, check out our newsletter, Profit from Operations.

Latest posts in our blog